← All posts

Why Three Bids Are Not the Way to Pick a Contractor

Why Three Bids Are Not the Way to Pick a Contractor

Getting three bids feels like the responsible thing to do. Everyone from your neighbor to your parents has told you to do it. The problem is that on a high-cost remodel, three bids from the same set of plans aren't three prices for the same project. They're three guesses.

Plans almost never show everything: what's behind the walls, the condition of the plumbing, electrical and HVAC, or the hundreds of product and finish decisions that haven't been made yet. Each contractor fills those gaps with their own assumptions, so you end up comparing apples to oranges and calling it due diligence.

The lowest number is usually the one that left the most out

The lowest number usually wins, and that's where homeowners get hurt. The low bid is very often the one with light allowances, vague exclusions, and nothing for the existing conditions nobody looked at. That money doesn't disappear. It comes back as change orders in the middle of construction, after your kitchen is torn out and you can't walk away. The "cheapest" contractor ends up costing the most, and the stress of that process is something no bid sheet will ever show you.

The side of this most homeowners never hear

Pricing a high-end remodel the right way takes real time: walking the home, understanding the systems, getting sub pricing, and nailing down specs. Process-driven contractors know this, so many of them simply won't do free bids. The contractors who will turn a number around quickly from plans alone are either guessing or folding the cost of all the jobs they didn't win into the ones they do. Without realizing it, the three-bid approach can filter out the exact contractor you were hoping to find.

A better approach

Pick your contractor first, then build the price together. Interview them. Ask how they handle pre-construction, how they set allowances, how change orders work, and what their warranty looks like. Talk to past clients.

Then pay for a real pre-construction process that ends with permit-ready plans, finished selections, and a detailed proposal you can actually count on. You'll spend a little up front, but you'll be comparing contractors on what really matters, their process, instead of on a number that was never real in the first place.

Free guideThe Part Most Builders Skip (and you pay for later)Our design and pre-construction guide — free, with no commitment. Emailed to you.